|
"Voltaire
Ltd" and its selling shareholders are offering 7,693,000 share in price
range of $12.00 and $14.00 per share. Company
is incorporated
under the laws of the State of Israel in April 1997.
Company is a leading provider
of server and storage
switching and software solutions based
on the InfiniBand architecture as well as grid management
software that
enable high-performance grid computing within the data center. Its solutions allow one or
more discrete computing clusters to be linked
together as a single unified computing resource, or fabric.
Simply
said company provides solutions for cluster to cluster
networking with high-performance interconnects normally known
as grid computing or grid formation (a cluster
normally consist of a high performance server and auxiliary
storage units).
Company intended to use the net proceeds from this offering for research and development activities,
expand its business development and marketing activities, for
general corporate purposes, working capital, and to repay a loan with an outstanding principal amount of $5.0
million. It may also use a portion of the net proceeds to acquire
or invest in complementary companies, products or
technologies.
Financials
($ in thousands)
Company's
financial year ends on December 31.
| |
FY
2005
|
FY
2006 |
%Growth |
Q1
FY 2006*
|
Q1
FY 2007*
|
%Growth |
|
Revenue
|
15,366 |
30,427 |
98.02% |
4,389 |
8,580 |
95.49% |
|
Gross
profit |
4,536
|
11,204 |
147.00% |
1,543 |
3,189 |
106.68% |
|
Operating
loss
|
(10,107) |
(8,305) |
|
(2,775) |
(2,610) |
|
*Quarter
ended March 31
Business/Company
Outlook
Data warehouse/Data
center business is growing at rapid pace and expected to keep or
rather extend its pace in future, this growth will in turn
will create more and more demand for switching, networking (grid
computing) products and solutions. As per estimates overall
grid computing market will grow from $3.9 billion in 2006 to
$6.9 billion by 2010.
"Voltaire"
revenues has shown considerable growth in last few years from
$0.5 million in FY 2004 to $3 million in FY 2006, company shows
this growth mainly due to commercialization of few of its
developed products in these years. Although despite this
growth company is still making loss at net as well as
operating level mainly due to high research & development expenses,
high sales and marketing expenses, but benefit of these
expenses is clearly reflected in its ever rising revenues with
introduction of new products. High spending on Sales and marketing help company
to not only grew its revenue but also enable it to build up a
highly impressive OEM relationships will biggies like HP, IBM,
Sun Microsystems, Silicon Graphics and NEC Corporation that accounts for more then 60% of company's revenue. These
relationships itself reflects rising acceptance of products
developed by company in market.
Voltaire
is a R&D based company which develop and sells products/solutions
for high end cluster to cluster linkage or networking (grid
computing) based on InfiniBand architecture. Company do most
of its R&D in-house, although it subcontract the manufacturing,
assembling and testing of its products to other contract
manufacturers.
Company
develop its products based on InfiniBand architecture but simultaneously
its products are flexible enough to work across multiple
architectures (like Ethernet, Fibre Channel), which allow
customers to install its products without replacing their
existing infrastructure, further its relationship with OEM
suppliers not only allow it to introduce its products to
potential customers but also allow its customers to compare
its products with products based on competing architectures,
which in turn allow company to show superiority of its
products over other products. Since its products normally
cater to the high end grid computing market like data centers
with large installation, normally it earns its revenue from
few big size orders which make it open to quarter to
quarter and even year to year revenue fluctuations as wining
or losing one big deal/client will make revenues rise or
decline steeply.
Company's
principal competitors are Cisco Systems, Inc. and QLogic
Corporation.
Currently
company is working with operating margins of nearly -30%
and the only way to convert these negative margins
to positive is by growth in revenue because there is no possibility
of reduction in R&D expenditure, sales and marketing
expenditure in absolute numbers these expenditures can only be
reduce in % terms as compare to revenue.
Valuation/Offer
value ($ in thousand)
(Company may not be able to
perform this well, chances of company performing this well is, four
out of five)
Assume
that company shows (assuming that, nothing
negative happen with company and it perform just ok,
although due to growth potential of its business and
strong R&D, company has potential to grow faster
and can perform better than these
assumptions.)
(Assumptions
includes the effect of debt repayment from funds raised
through this offering.)
1.
65% percent rise in revenue year on year in FY 2007 and FY
2008 from $30427 in FY 2006 to $50205 in
FY 2007 and to further $82838 in FY 2008.
Historically
company's revenues are growing at nearly 100% per year but on
lower base now on bigger base we assume company's revenue
growth rate can decline, although there are still very good
chances that company can maintain its historically growth
rate.
2.
Gross margins rises by 5% each year from 37% in FY 2006
to 42% in FY 2007 and further to 47% in 2008.
Gross
margins can rise on account of two things, higher sales of
high margin products and economy of scale due to higher sales.
3.
Operating profit margins improves from
-27% in FY 2006 to -7% in FY 2007 and further
to 9% in FY 2008.
Operating
margins can improve due to higher gross margins. Reduction of
R&D expenditure, sales and marketing expenditure in % term
as compare to revenue.
This
leave company with operating (loss)/profit of
($3515) and $7456 in FY 2007 and FY 2008 respectively and after detecting interest
cost of nearly $99 and $99 and income tax @ 29%** this leave
company with net loss/ profit of ($3613) and $5223, that is EPS of $
(0.18) and $ 0.26 for FY 07 and FY 08 respectively.
| ($
in thousand) |
| FY
2006 |
Assume |
%
change |
FY 2007 |
FY
2008 |
| $30427 |
Rise in revenue |
65% |
50204.55 |
82837.51 |
| 37% |
Gross margins
rise |
5%
per year |
42% |
47% |
| -27% |
Operating
margins |
-7%(2007),
9%(2008) |
(3514.32) |
7455.38 |
| |
interest
cost |
|
$99 |
$99 |
| |
income tax |
@ 29%** |
|
2133.35 |
| |
Net loss/ profit |
|
(3613) |
5223 |
This
means if nothing negative happen with company and it perform just ok, at offer
price of $13 company's share is available at two year forward PE of nearly
51.
| |
Earning
per share |
Forward
PE
(
At offer price of $13) |
| FY
2007 |
$
-0.18 |
-- |
| FY
2008 |
$
0.26 |
51 |
**
Israeli
companies are generally subject to corporate tax at the rate
of 29% of their taxable income in 2007. The rate is scheduled
to decline to 27% in 2008, 26% in 2009 and 25% in 2010 and
thereafter.
We rate this IPO
2- on scale of "1 to
5" (5 for best)
Negatives
-
Company's
loss making history.
-
Offer
price extremely high.
-
Any
introduction of new technology/product better than
company's can hit company hard.
-
Low
cash flow.
-
Revenues
can fluctuate quarter on quarter and even year on year due
to nature of industry.
Positives
-
High
growth rate of company as well as industry.
-
Any
acquisition will accelerate this growth rate further.
-
Healthy
balance sheet. (after this offering).
-
Possible
breakeven in near future.
-
Strong
R&D.
-
OEM
relationship with big companies.
-
Funds
raised from this offering will give company much needed
financial strength to develop and market its products
worldwide and to compete with other big players more
effectively.
-
Currently
company is paying 3.5% royalty on its revenue to repay the
grants it used for its R&D needs till FY2005. As of
March 31, 2007, the royalty amount payable was
approximately $4.4 million. Since FY 2006 company is not utilizing
any R&D grants, So ones the outstanding amount of $4.4
million get repaid by company in about two years its
operating margins will further improve by 3.5%.
This article reflects personal view of the author
about the company and one must read offer prospectus and
consult its financial adviser before making any investment
decision

|